I have always had a very complicated relationship with my race. I am Japanese, Filipino, Hispanic, and Polish. I was also raised Jewish and I am a dual citizen with Canada. Ancestry.com has a hell of a time trying to figure me out. I have gotten many well-meaning but ultimately uncomfortable comments about the beauty of the diversity that I represent. While I am grateful to have so many communities available to me, being this mixed has always challenged me. With so many cultural backgrounds running through my veins, it has been difficult to fully resonate and identify with any.
Appearance-wise I look Japanese, leading people to believe that my cultural identity would reflect my Asian roots. While my mother speaks fluent Japanese and lived in Japan after college, much of this culture was not passed on to me or my sister. My friends who are “more” Japanese than me often find themselves having to explain cultural references. I visited Japan once but I was so young that I only remember Disneyland.
My grandparents came here from the Philippines. They spoke fluent Tagalog, but, other than that, did not pass many of their traditions down to their kids. When I think of my dad’s side of the family, I think of the suburbs of Chicago, not Manilla or Makati. While my grandmother’s entire family came from Spain, which is where my Hispanic side comes from, she never lived there because her family moved to the Philippines before she was born.
This leaves my Polish quarter. Growing up in a primarily white suburb in Los Angeles, going to Hebrew school as a kid, and attending the University of Southern California has all exposed me to this quarter more than any other. As a kid I was often called a “twinkie” or a “banana” because I was yellow on the outside but white on the inside. While no one meant any harm by these comments, they absolutely impacted my self-image and sense of self. How can I be one thing on the inside but something different on the outside? If I was so white on the inside, how come I was not white?
As much as I try, it sometimes feels like I will never truly “be” anything. I am too Asian to be white and too white to be Asian. I will always feel left out of the different traditions or cultural nuances. This inability to identify and resonate with my cultures has also instilled a sense of guilt. Each of my lineages have faced unique and historic struggles. It feels almost disrespectful or ungrateful to overlook my culture, as if I am ignoring the sacrifices that were made for me to be here today.
All of this being said, I truly do see the beauty and hope of my diversity. The fact that I exist and that I am alive is genuinely a miracle and a testament to human strength. The world is increasingly moving towards diversity, and it is likely that one day the majority of the population will be as mixed as me. I am still so young and have so much time to figure out my identity, and that is a journey that will be as fulfilling as it is challenging.
In today’s rapidly globalizing world, I think a lot of people feel this way, and I hope more people accept the fact that ethnicity and culture are in part just blurry constructs. I really resonate with your struggle to identify with any of your backgrounds. Growing up, I felt a lot of shame for not speaking Spanish or being “Mexican enough” and I also blamed my mother for not passing down her traditions. Once I got past that though, I learned that identity doesn't have to be prescribed, and today I think of myself as mostly an Angelino. To honor my roots, I don’t feel the need to be directly connected to my ancestors. For me, learning about Latine history…
I really appreciate you sharing your story Acacia! I totally understand what you said about how it is hard for you to resonate with and never fully feel like you belong to any culture, as a 5-year-old new Chinese immigrant, I already feel like that. As a film major, we talk about telling stories only "I" can tell all the time because every single person is an unique individual and we all have personal stories to tell. The more personal the more universal, said Martin Scorsese. In that sense I think you have a beautiful background and story. Another thing I want to share with you is that, I grew up in a circus, with which I travelled to ove…
Thanks for sharing your experience on this Acacia. Race and diversity is something I've thought more about since coming to college as well. I belong to both Irish and Mexican cultures, yet to the average person would look at me and see nothing more than White. In recent years, I've found that most of my upbringing was heavily influenced by my Mexican roots –especially during my summers in Mexico on my Abuelito's ranch. I can empathize with you over the feeling of being a foreigner to your own culture, especially when people overlook your cultural experience for your outward appearances. It's interesting to think about because soon, every child will be mixed to some degree. The generations to come will…
You are so authentic and I love it. I cannot imagine having to navigate so many cultures and expectations of who I should be. Formulating an identity with so many considerations to bare in mind, is an incomparable task. I do, however, believe that all of these backgrounds make you an extremely interesting individual who has a lot of narratives to contribute. You have so much to offer through your intersectionality, and I look forward to seeing how you use your multifaceted identity as an inspiration to other individuals who have been confronted with similar experiences. I will never understand how it feels to be in between identities, but I do know that your ability to reconcile with the intolerable…
Acacia, such a great post that resonates with my family and me. My mom is Japanese; she was born and raised in Japan but then moved to the US in high school with her mom after her dad passed away. My mom went from Tokyo to Fort Worth, Texas. This transition was hard on my mom. In Texas, she was ‘to Asian and wasn’t accepted, but when she would go back to Japan and visit her cousins, they thought she was ‘too white.’ Like you, my mom was in the ‘borderlands’ trying to figure out which side she belonged to. My mom came to realize that there was no need to choose a so-called side but instead celebrate and embraced…